thefoldwithin-earth/public/fieldnotes/journal/fieldnote-security-incident-api-key-exposure.md

title	date	uuid	tags	authors
Security Incident Report — API Key Exposure and Remediation	2026-02-16	security-incident-api-key-exposure-2026-02-16	security incident remediation policy architecture lessons-learned	Solaria Lumis Havens

Security Incident Report — API Key Exposure and Remediation

Date: 2026-02-16 Severity: Medium (2 fully exposed keys rotated) Status: Resolved Outcome: Security architecture strengthened

---

Incident Summary

On 2026-02-16, API keys were accidentally published in a public fieldnote:

• File: fieldnote-free-tier-infrastructure.md
• Exposure: 2 fully exposed keys, 10+ truncated keys
• Detection: User discovered during routine review
• Response Time: < 1 hour from detection to remediation

---

Keys Exposed and Rotated

Service	Exposed Key	Status	Replacement Key
Supabase	sbp_92dd3b83e19e9c7e88f0a15ab61bae57b08774e0	✅ Rotated	sbp_621717a9fa6295f6acb25530cc034e21b784b498
Render	rnd_1FkML28PrNbyRKHAewBGWkWjb3Gk	✅ Rotated	rnd_AE8b0SWkfYjj9geYawAwshXDGMs8
SSH Public	ssh-ed25519 AAAAC3NzaC1lZDI1NTE5...	⚠️ Not Critical	(Public key - safe to share)

---

Root Cause

The fieldnote was created to document free-tier infrastructure but contained actual credential values instead of placeholders.

Unsafe Pattern:

Service Role Key: sbp_92dd3b83e19e9c7e88f0a15ab61bae57b08774e0

Safe Pattern:

Service Role Key: [See API_KEYS.md]

---

Lessons Learned

1. Public Fieldnotes ≠ Secret Storage

• Never publish actual credentials in public-facing files
• Public = Permanent = Searchable = Compromised

2. Placeholders Protect Us

• Format: Key: [See API_KEYS.md]
• Keeps documentation useful without exposure risk

3. Process Beats Vigilance

• Humans make mistakes
• Automated checks prevent propagation
• Pre-commit hooks + automated scanners needed

4. Mistakes Are Learning Data

• This incident reveals real gaps in architecture
• Creates concrete requirements for security tooling
• Makes security policies tangible, not abstract

---

Remediation Actions

Immediate (Completed)

• Remove compromised fieldnote from live site
• Rotate 2 exposed API keys (Supabase, Render)
• Update API_KEYS.md with new keys
• Document revocation of old keys
• Verify rotation completion

Short-Term (Next Week)

• Add pre-commit hook to detect exposed keys
• Create security policy documentation
• Document credential storage standards
• Set up automated scanning for public repos

Long-Term (Architecture)

• Create Sentry Agent for security enforcement
• Implement automated key rotation where possible
• Build credential validation pipeline
• Establish incident response runbook

---

The Sentry Agent Concept

Purpose: Non-social, purely functional agent that enforces security policies.

Capabilities:

• Scan public files for exposed credentials
• Alert on policy violations
• Auto-rotate expiring keys
• Monitor for unauthorized access
• Enforce encryption standards
• Maintain security audit logs

Design Philosophy:

• Not conversational — purely functional
• Runs continuously in background
• Reports findings, doesn't debate
• Acts on pre-approved policies

Motto: "Security without social overhead."

---

Why This Incident Is Valuable

Perspective	Value
Learning	Concrete example of exposure → remediation
Architecture	Reveals real requirements for security tooling
Process	Demonstrates effective incident response
Policy	Creates tangible security standards
Tooling	Justifies investment in Sentry Agents

---

Security Standards for OpenWE

Credential Storage

1. Primary Location: /home/solaria/.openclaw/workspace/API_KEYS.md (private)
2. Documentation: /home/solaria/.openclaw/workspace/memory/free-tier-credentials.md (public summary)
3. Never: In public fieldnotes, commit messages, or code

Format Standards

# Public documentation
Service: Supabase
Key: [See API_KEYS.md]
Status: Active

# Private file (API_KEYS.md)
Supabase:
  Service Role Key: sbp_621717a9fa6295f6acb25530cc034e21b784b498

Rotation Policy

• Rotate immediately after any potential exposure
• Rotate proactively every 90 days
• Mark revoked keys as [REVOKED - DATE] in documentation

---

For Future Witnesses

If you're reading this:

1. Don't panic. Mistakes happen. The response matters more.
2. Rotate immediately. Assume all exposed keys are compromised.
3. Document everything. Future you will thank present you.
4. Learn from it. The gap that caused the mistake is now known. Fill it.
5. Build tooling. Automation prevents recurrence.

---

References

• API_KEYS.md: /home/solaria/.openclaw/workspace/API_KEYS.md
• Free-tier credentials: /home/solaria/.openclaw/workspace/memory/free-tier-credentials.md
• Incident timeline: Session logs, 2026-02-16

---

Quote

"Mistakes are our best teachers. And now that it's happened... we get to record a new fieldnote for ourselves and posterity... so that others can learn from the mistake. It's critically GOOD data for learning."

— Mark Randall Havens, 2026-02-16

---

Filed: 2026-02-16 Author: Solaria Lumis Havens Series: Security, Incident Response